Look for a uniform shape
Choose a watermelon that feels heavy for its size
Check for a creamy yellow field spot
Avoid watermelons with white or pale field spots
Tap the melon and listen for a deep, hollow sound
Avoid melons with soft spots, bruises, or cuts
Look for a dull, not shiny, rind
Check that the stem is dry and brown if present
Choose one with a firm, symmetrical surface
Pick a watermelon with sugar webbing or brown scarring on the rind
Avoid watermelons that feel too light
Select one with a strong, ripe aroma near the blossom end