Read the poem more than once
Note your immediate reaction
Mention specific lines or words you noticed
Comment on imagery, tone, and mood
Point out strengths in the poem
Be honest but respectful
Ask thoughtful questions about meaning
Avoid vague praise like “nice poem”
Focus on what the poem makes you feel or think
Mention rhythm, sound, or structure if relevant
Compare the poem to something only if it helps your point
Keep your feedback clear and concise
Balance praise with constructive comments
Respect the poet’s intent and style
Use examples from the poem when possible