Look for a creamy yellow field spot
Choose a watermelon that feels heavy for its size
Pick one with a dull, matte rind
Check for a uniform shape
Avoid soft spots, cuts, or bruises
Look for a dry, brown stem
Tap it for a deep, hollow sound
Choose one with strong contrast between stripes
Prefer a symmetrical melon without flat sides
Avoid watermelons with shiny skin
Pick one that feels firm all over
Look for webbing or sugar spots on the rind