Look for a creamy yellow field spot
Pick one that feels heavy for its size
Check for a dull, not shiny, rind
Choose one with a uniform shape
Tap it and listen for a deep, hollow sound
Avoid soft spots, cracks, or dents
Look for a dry, brown stem
Check that the rind is firm and unbroken
Prefer one with prominent dark green stripes or contrast
Avoid watermelons that feel too light
Choose one that has a symmetrical shape
Look for a slight give only at the blossom end, not overall softness