Look for a creamy yellow field spot
Choose one that feels heavy for its size
Check for a dull, not shiny, rind
Tap it and listen for a deep, hollow sound
Pick one with a firm, symmetrical shape
Avoid cracks, soft spots, or dents
Look for a dry, brown stem or vine
Check for sugar webbing or brown scarring on the rind
Avoid watermelons with overly bright or pale skin
Smell the blossom end for a sweet aroma