It gives slightly when gently pressed
It has a sweet, fragrant smell at the stem end
The skin has a deep, even color for its variety
It feels heavy for its size
The flesh is not rock-hard
The stem end is slightly soft
It comes off the tree easily, if freshly picked
It has minimal green coloring near the stem
It is free of major bruises, wrinkles, or shriveling
It tastes sweet and juicy when sampled