Looks symmetrical and evenly shaped
Has a dull, matte rind rather than a shiny one
Feels heavy for its size
Has a creamy yellow field spot
Has a dry, brown stem or no stem
Makes a deep, hollow sound when tapped
Has firm skin with no soft spots
Has no major cracks, cuts, or bruises
Has sugar webbing or brown scarring on the rind
Feels dense and solid when lifted