Severe pain right after the injury
Swelling around the toe
Bruising or discoloration
Toe looks crooked, bent, or out of place
Pain when walking or putting weight on the foot
Trouble moving the toe
Tenderness when touching the toe
A popping or cracking sound at the time of injury
Numbness or tingling
Toenail damage or bleeding under the nail
Pain that does not improve after rest, ice, and elevation
Need for an X-ray to confirm the break