Bright, even skin color for the variety
Slightly soft when gently pressed
Flaps or “wings” starting to dry or brown
Fruit feels heavy for its size
Skin looks plump, not shriveled
Comes off the plant easily with a gentle twist
Aroma is mild and sweet near the stem
No green patches on fully colored varieties
Flesh yields slightly, not mushy
Best harvested when skin is fully colored and texture is just tender